Objective cosmogenesis reassessment

Public correction · first issued 4 August 2026 · status update 21 September 2026 · Nanjie Ma · ORCID 0009-0002-4415-1209
About / Work subpage. Not a homepage hero. Not a ranking. Not a breakthrough notice. Not cosmogenesis payment.

The same ruler for every programme. Credit what is deposited. Do not convert a deposited object into cosmogenesis closure. Do not convert a neighbour’s real result into a weak competitor.
Correction of record (still in force). Earlier website pages displayed programme-internal composite scores such as QNM 5.87, Tier-U 1/3 read as a truth fraction, and T1–T9 means. Those numbers mixed scientific delivery, checklist coverage, internal audit density, and narrative ambition. They are not probabilities of truth, and they are not evidence that QNM is ahead in cosmogenesis. Programme-level flags remain: physical_genesis_truth=false, breakthrough=false, theorem_L6_closure=false, preprint_hold=true.

1. Shared ruler

Sky-fitting, continuum geometry, and cosmogenesis-from-a-source are different questions. A result that answers one question is not a score on the others. This page uses that split for QNM and for its neighbours alike.

2. What changed after 4 August 2026

The August correction remains the reading of the old composite scores. What has changed is one QNM object, not the cosmogenesis verdict.

Covering-kernel covariant dynamics is now a citable, classified object: finite-horizon covariant coherent laws form a simplex; the birth share is boundary data; certified trajectories are ladders; a thinning semigroup on that locus selects the chain. Proofs and later covering-kernel deposits occupy the companions listed on the covering-kernel on-record page (through Companions 40, 42, 47, 48, 49, 50 and 51 as of 15 November 2026; Companion 41 is not listed). Spectral algebra, negatives, the form note, and the independent manuscript occupy their own class pages. See Covering-kernel covariant dynamics: foundational work on record.

That deposit does not pay cosmogenesis. Typical covering-generated orders remain chain-like at reachable event-count; they are not four-dimensional spacetime. Lorentzian structure, the continuum limit, a unique issuance law, and an interpolating constructor from this kernel to later layers remain unpaid. The covering kernel is not a licence to say that QNM has overtaken CDT, causal sets, or inflation on those later axes.

On the live native-dynamics cell used for even-handed comparison, QNM scores 1. The reviewed neighbours that have a scoped dynamics object also score 1. Nobody scores 2. A cell at 1 is granted scoped dynamics, not payment.

3. Historical score correction (4 August 2026)

The table below is the August correction of the old mixed axes. It is retained as provenance. It is not the live public ruler, and it is not recomputed here into a new QNM lead.

ReadingQNM resultInterpretation
Legacy 11-axis mean0.545 / 2Historical only; mixed process and science.
Recommended value on the same old axes0.364 / 2Corrects data falsifiability from 1 to 0 and reproducibility deposit from 2 to 1.
Scientific-delivery axes (4 August reading)0.111 / 2Then: one partial point for degrees-of-freedom transparency. That reading pre-dates the covering-kernel classification and the later native-dynamics cell at 1. It is not a live ranking.
Process-integrity axes1.5 / 2Strong local deposit and claim-audit practice; not a truth-proximity score.

The old “own 7/9 versus peers 5–7/9” result is retained only as coverage under a QNM-specific internal checklist. It is not an objective cross-theory truth ranking. The 20 July 2026 T1–T9 table (own mean 8.111) is the same kind of archival snapshot.

4. Live public readings

QuestionEven-handed reading now
What does the sky look like?ΛCDM / Planck. QNM does not claim a χ² victory.
Is cosmogenesis closed?Nobody on this page. QNM flags remain unpaid.
Native dynamics paid (score 2)?Nobody. QNM and reviewed neighbours with a scoped dynamics object sit at 1.
Lorentzian spacetime / continuum from the covering kernel?Unpaid. CDT’s spectral-dimension flow is a different, real deposit; it is not transferred to QNM.
Checkable record-gate homework?QNM has filed Soft Hold B1. That is one of three house-gates (live public 1/3). It is not cosmogenesis closure, and it is not a score against ΛCDM.
Covering-kernel covariant dynamics classified?Yes, as a scoped mathematical object. Foundational work of that direction, not of cosmogenesis as a field.

The live public house-gate page is Which step is filed? (still 1/3). Older navigation that said “ahead of peers” is withdrawn.

5. What QNM has, and what it does not

Has (scoped, checkable):

Does not have (same bar as neighbours):

6. Is continued research justified?

Yes, on a bounded reading, for QNM and for the neighbours alike. A classified source-cut and a stack of scoped theorems are enough to keep working. They are not enough to say that cosmogenesis is close. The same sentence applies to causal-set sequential growth and to CDT’s dynamical geometry: deposited objects justify continuation; they do not close the field.

QNM work should continue while it can deliver a later-layer constructor that is not already implied by the covering kernel, a non-fabricated issuance law, or a scoped negative theorem with independent mathematical value. Renaming free couplings, initial states, or protocol constants is a stop condition. CDT, causal sets, inflation, and ΛCDM should be read by their own deposits on the same split, not as trophies or as foils.

Two layers, not one. A research direction can already be a citable mathematical object. Cosmogenesis closure is a later event. Those two layers should not be welded — for QNM, or for anyone else on this page.

7. Evidence and scope

August correction register: CT1360_OBJECTIVE_COMPETITOR_SCORE_AND_THRESHOLD_DRIFT_AUDIT_V1_LATEST.json. Covering-kernel public deposits: the parent preprint and the companions listed on the covering-kernel on-record page (through Companions 40, 42, 47, 48, 49, 50 and 51 as of 15 November 2026; Companion 41 is not listed). Other live classes: spectral algebra, negatives, form note, independent manuscript. External checks used in the original reassessment include Planck 2018 inflation constraints, the 2023 Everpresent-Lambda review, and CDT reviews. This page is a correction and status disclosure, not peer review and not a discovery claim.